April 19 2024

CSI Files

An archive of CSI, NCIS, Criminal Minds and crime drama news

Site Columns

By Kristine
June 7, 2004 - 9:56 PM

Hello World!

After reading a lot of reviews, quotes, and commentary about the CSI shows over the last few months, there a couple of trends/common themes I've seen, one of which bugs me. I notice David Caruso often gets taken to task for his performance in CSI: Miami and frankly, I'm puzzled as to why. Horatio Caine is a caring, determined, and passionate detective, and Caruso is excellent at telegraphing the tiniest nuances, be it Horatio's suspicion over a suspect's story, or his compassion for the family of a victim. So I've come up with a couple of theories as to why Caruso gets such a tough rap.

Admittedly, Horatio sometimes comes off as a slick character. Unlike William Petersen on CSI who delivers clever quips with an understated calm, Caruso has a smooth, arch way of saying things that make those slick lines come out as just that: slick. But that's part of the fun of Miami: Horatio's sunglasses, his hands on his hips (something reviewers and viewers seem to object to) and his witty comebacks all contribute to the powerful atmosphere Miami possesses. Miami is a slick town, and quick-witted Horatio fits right in.

Horatio probably couldn't be much more different from Petesen's Gil Grissom. Whereas Grissom often comes across as detached, Horatio is clearly passionate about his cases. An emotional case leads Grissom to half-confess his feelings for Sara (but not to Sara; rather, to a murder suspect); a devastating case causes Horatio to promise a fifteen-year-old girl that he won't give up until he can tell her she's safe. The two men aren't cut from the same mold; Grissom is a scientist, a man who is doggedly determined to see each case to completion, but not necessarily for emotional reasons. On the other hand, Horatio expresses as much concern for the survivors as he does for the victims, a characteristic that nicely balances his witty one-liners.

And then there's NYPD Blue. Many viewers probably haven't forgiven Caruso for his arrogant abandonment of the series that made him a star. I admit, before watching CSI: Miami, I had my doubts. But it's been ten years since he left Blue, and Caruso deserves to be forgiven for it. He's turning in such a good performance on CSI: Miami that it would be a darn shame not to let Caruso's past history go.

Trek BBS Today

Below are some of the topics currently being discussed at the Talk CSI Files BBS:

-CSI: NY Personal Lives

-Am I Seeing Things?

-Ending of "Innocent" question

More topics can be found at the Talk CSI Files BBS!

Poll Results

Below are the results of the most recent TrekToday poll:

If there is a fourth 'CSI' series, should it debut...
...never, as the franchise is already being spread too thin? 63.7% - (153 Votes)
...next season? 11.2% - (27 Votes)
...after one of the other shows goes off the air? 10% - (24 Votes)
...after a 'CSI' big-screen feature to launch it? 8.3% - (20 Votes)
...on cable, where the show could stretch boundaries not permissible on network TV? 6.6% - (16 Votes)

Total Votes: 240


Today's Television Listings

Tonight at 10pm, CBS will air the CSI: Miami episode "Witness to Murder". Here is TV Guide's description of the episode:

    A diamond broker carrying $2 million in merchandise is murdered after his car is hit by another vehicle and he gets out to confront the driver. The only witness to the crime is a developmentally challenged man who says the killer is someone named Colton. Outside of town, Speedle and Delko investigate the death of a teenage girl discovered at a rest stop with a broken neck. Shortly after the victim is taken from the scene, her body disappears during transport to Miami.

On Thursday, CBS will show CSI: Crime Scene Investigation's episode "After the Show". Here is how TV Guide describes the episode:

    Catherine takes the lead in finding a missing model, believed to be dead, after the prime suspect insists on talking only to her. The news doesn't sit well with Sara and Nick, who each hope to use the case to improve their chances of getting a promotion.

Discuss this news item at Talk CSI!
XML Add CSI Files RSS feed to your news reader or My Yahoo!
Also a Desperate Housewives fan? Then visit GetDesperate.com!

Find more episode info in the Episode Guide.

You may have missed